The debate has waged on for many years regarding the acidity of pine straw (also typically known as pine needles and pinestraw mulch) and the results that potential acidity may have on soil acidity and subsequent plant health when utilised as a mulch. I’ve study in many places that pine straw is acidic, it will switch your soil acidic, and only crops that like acidic soil can be developed with pine straw as mulch. Dependent on my comprehensive past experience, I have publicly disputed that assertion by stating that despite the fact that pine straw in alone is somewhat acidic, as it breaks down it gets to be considerably less acidic in excess of time and has no genuine negative result on soil acidity or plant overall health. I’ve done some simple research in the earlier to help that argument, but have been interested in even more study and screening in get to bolster that declare.

Lately, I started performing analytic screening of the acidity, or pH (outlined beneath), of different ages and forms of pine straw and soil to assist in separating truth from fiction. The final results of those assessments are summarized below.

If you usually are not acquainted with the time period pH, it is just a measure of a substance’s acidity or alkalinity based on a variety (scale) of to fourteen, with seven. currently being regarded as neutral, much less than 7 currently being defined as acidic, and better than seven getting outlined as becoming alkaline.

Sometimes the pH scale can be a minor deceptive though. For instance, we know that rain drinking water is healthy for our gardens and we normally consider of it as currently being “pure” and thus somewhat “neutral.” But, rain h2o actually has a regular pH of among five.5 and six., which is slightly acidic on the pH scale. Ahead of you decide to swear off the advantages of rain drinking water however, relaxation confident it is even now a safe and healthier guess for your crops, one purpose of which I’ll talk about later on in this report.

My very first check consisted of green needles, pulled refreshing from the tree. As in all of the needle and soil tests, the needles have been placed in a non-reactive container and combined with an acceptable volume of distilled water adhering to standard analytical tests recommendations and making use of a suitable and calibrated pH meter (one human body electrode making use of normal buffer remedies). The pH of pure distilled drinking water in the container was six.four. Right after adding the needles for ten minutes of soak time, the pH of the eco-friendly needles was 6.three. To simulate rain h2o flushing to figure out the pH of the leachate of the needles, the needles had been authorized to soak for 24 hours and the resulting pH was four.5. To further simulate the normal rain and drying cycle, the needles ended up rinsed and then permitted to dry outside for 7 days. The 24 hour soak examination was then repeated and the pH was 5.. The rinsing, 7 day drying cycle and 24 hour soak examination was once again repeated, adopted by two individual fourteen working day drying cycles and 24 hour soak assessments. The pH benefits were 5.1, six.2, and six.5 respectively. From this spherical of checks, it is distinct that the fresh eco-friendly needles leachate was at first acidic at 4.five, but following several simulations of rain and drying cycles more than a few months time, the solution (the conditions leachate and solution are utilised interchangeably listed here) was at the equivalent of rainwater pH. Above a interval of forty six times, the needles have been no for a longer time acidic, with the pH being that of distilled h2o.

The next check consisted of freshly fallen needles, the variety that would usually be gathered and utilised as mulch. After twenty minutes of soak time, the pH of the pine straw (the phrases pine needles and pine straw can and are employed interchangeably below) was six.6. As with the inexperienced needle testing, this check series consisted of an initial 24 hour soak test which was then adopted by a seven day drying cycle, 24 hour soak test, and then two 14 day drying cycles and 24 hour soak tests. The pH benefits of this series of exams ended up, four.nine, 6., and 6. respectively. In about 3 weeks the acidity of freshly fallen pine straw was diminished to that of rain h2o. After 38 times, the pH was increased to six.. Subsequent the sample of the environmentally friendly needle assessments the pH probably would get to that of distilled h2o in the identical time frame.

The 3rd take a look at used a blend of entire and damaged needles that had been bagged and kept dry and out of sunlight since their selection in excess of a span of about six months to 1 year prior to the take a look at. Following 30 minutes of soak time, the pH of the pine straw was 5.8. This take a look at was adopted by an first 24 hour soak check resulting in a pH of four.7. Because the 24 hour soak examination outcome was within the selection envisioned primarily based on previous exams, a seven day soak examination was introduced at this position to seem for evidence that for a longer time rain saturation simulation cycles may increase pH at a fee quicker than shorter rain simulation cycles. With the end result following 7 times being five.three, the leaching rate appears to generally comply with the exact same price of the preceding tests that used shorter soak and for a longer time drying cycles.

For my fourth examination, I used decomposed items of needles that ended up approximately three months to 2 years previous. These parts ended up taken from the yard and at the base of a 5 to six inch deep pine straw mulch layer. This mulch has been continuously additional to, with the best layer currently being placed there as lately as 3 months back, and the base as lengthy as two several years back. The main intent of this check was to decide if downward leaching impacted reduced amounts of mulch. After 30 minutes of soak time, the pH of the pine straw was four.9. This check was followed by an original 24 hour soak take a look at resulting in a pH of four.9 and then a seven working day soak test, after which, the pH was raised to 5.six. These benefits to begin with propose that downward leaching may possibly take place, but for a longer time saturation decreased the pH of the leachate speedily and to that of rain h2o.

My fifth examination utilized decomposed parts of needles that had been roughly 1 yr old and received from the topmost layer of pine straw in a sunny and extremely dry location of my yard. Soon after 30 minutes of soak time, the pH of the pine straw was six.nine, which was followed by a 24 hour soak take a look at ensuing in a pH of 6.. The two of these outcomes follow the same prior designs of decreased leachate acidity more than time.

The remaining exams were carried out on soil native to my location to establish the extended time period impact of pine straw leachate on soil pH over time.

My initial soil test was performed on clean soil not uncovered to any pine straw or its leachate with a pH end result of six.5.

The next test utilized soil received in the identical spot, but from under a five to six inch deep pine straw mulch layer that consisted of a single yr aged decomposed pieces of pine needles. The pH result was seven.four. Owing to the unexpected outcomes of this test (expectation was that it would be equal to or lower than the very first examination), the pH meter was recalibrated and the examination was recurring on a new soil sample taken from a diverse place in the same general area. The consequence of that take a look at was equivalent to the original check, returning a pH of 7.four.

The third check consisted of soil that is below a ten to twelve inch layer of 6 thirty day period aged pine straw mulch positioned below a few 50 yr old pine trees that have continually bombarded the soil with slightly acidic pine needles. The preliminary expectation prior to this third take a look at was the soil would be very acidic with a pH decrease than the benefits in the 1st two exams. The actual check uncovered a pH of seven.4, the same as the location with five to six inches of a single calendar year aged decomposed straw. Dependent on the background sample that was not uncovered to pine straw used in the first soil test, it appears that the soil in the second and third exams experienced buffered any leachate acidity to in close proximity to neutral levels.

The main objective of this specific collection of testing and analysis was to decide if pine straw leachate was acidic and if so, did that leachate in turn produce acidic soil situations that may trigger a damaging affect to crops. In summary, right here is what the screening final results expose:

Green pine needles are acidic but lose their acidity in excess of a brief period of time of time as they dry out and are uncovered to rain and exterior weather conditions circumstances. Green needles aren’t generally employed as mulch, but if had been to be, even more tests would be needed to decide more time term soil impacts of employing the higher acidity inexperienced needles.
Freshly fallen needles, the type that are typically used as mulch, are somewhat acidic when refreshing, but within approximately 3 weeks of slipping from the trees, leach a answer that is about the equivalent of rainwater.
Downward leaching of some acidity may possibly happen when new needles are utilised above more mature needles, but the soil buffers it with no damaging acidic affect to the soil itself. This could be a partial explanation as to why weed seeds wrestle to germinate in pinestraw mulch.
More mature straw carries on to lose acidity in excess of time when exposed to rain and outdoors temperature circumstances.
Soils can buffer the slight acidity of freshly fallen needles and as a result, there is no damaging effect to crops from the slight acidity of pine straw when utilized as mulch.

So why do so numerous individuals think pine straw mulch is only excellent on crops necessitating an acidic soil?” This will come from the common misunderstanding that pine needles are “very” acidic and as a result will change your soil “extremely” acidic and injury non acid-loving vegetation. We know soil pH is very critical to plant health. It straight impacts the plant’s ability to take up soil vitamins and minerals that it calls for to develop, thrive, and fight off diseases, as nicely as to take in any herbicides, pesticides or fungicides used to struggle ailments or pests that can injure or eliminate it. This potential is at its highest when the soil pH is between about five.eight and 6.5. Based on that, my test conclusions are substantial in that the pH of the freshly fallen pine straw leachate was six. at a few weeks time. Most pine straw will be at the very least 3 months previous by the time it is harvested, created accessible for acquire (or collected yourself), and employed in your backyard. So the leachate that would achieve your plants’ roots and bordering soil would not only be the equivalent of rainwater, but also in the perfect variety for maximum nutrient absorption. Even the preliminary examination final results of 4.nine and over the first two weeks screening time period are insignificant, as the potential of soils and roots to buffer pH are commonly acknowledged and understood.

So for people who hold up their wholesome, lively and substantial flower and vegetable producing acid-loving crops as an instance of the merits of the acidity of pine straw, I wholeheartedly concur. But for about employing it on their not so acid-loving vegetation, consider these houses that let it to outperform other mulches and let your vegetation to expand and thrive equally as nicely as their acid loving brethren:

it supplies the best degree of acidity for your plants to take in optimum soil vitamins
it doesn’t float and wash absent and breaks down far more little by little, so it isn’t going to need to be reapplied as often as other mulches
it is less complicated to manage and lighter per cubic foot than other mulches: one particular big bale can cover as significantly region as 30 cubic feet of most mulches
the price for each sq. foot is competitive with other mulches
it breathes much better, isn’t going to compact, and allows for far better water infiltration
it is simple to apply: just unroll the bales and scatter by hand
it isn’t going to draw in termites
it adds natural content and vitamins and minerals to soil and decreases weeds
the uniform color and wonderful texture of pine straw provides out the shade, contrast, and texture of your landscape
you can use it for erosion management the place grass won’t develop to keep soil, even on hillsides and paths


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here